At Merch Mates, our reviews help you decide what’s worth your time and money. Whether it’s a game, movie, TV show, or product, our scoring system is designed to offer clear, honest, and insightful evaluations. A score isn’t just a number—it’s a reflection of quality, execution, and overall experience.
No review is purely objective, but we strive for fair, transparent, and well-argued critiques. Each review we write considers four core factors:
Does it deliver on what it promises? Is it well-made?
Does it innovate or tell a compelling story?
Does it engage, excite, or move its audience?
Will it stand the test of time, or is it forgettable?
Simply put: this is the highest praise we can give. A masterpiece isn’t just great—it’s unforgettable. These are the experiences that set new standards, spark conversations for years, and inspire the next generation of creators.
📌 Flawless execution, emotional depth, and lasting impact.
📌 Not just entertainment—an experience that sticks with you.
📌 Future-proofed: It will be talked about for years to come.
A must-experience that flirts with perfection but doesn’t quite achieve legendary status. These are top-tier, finely crafted works that deliver memorable moments, technical polish, and deep emotional or intellectual engagement.
📌 Nearly flawless, with only minor hiccups.
📌 Innovative or exceptionally well-executed.
📌 Will be remembered as one of the best of its time.
A standout experience that’s well worth your time. It might not reinvent the wheel, but what it does, it does exceptionally well. If you’re a fan of the genre, this is a no-brainer.
📌 Polished, engaging, and well-designed.
📌 Not groundbreaking, but still one of the best in its class.
📌 Few notable flaws, but they don’t overshadow the positives.
A solid and enjoyable experience, but one that falls short of greatness. Maybe it’s a little unpolished, too familiar, or a step down from past entries, but it’s still worth checking out.
📌 Fans will enjoy it, but newcomers might not be won over.
📌 A fun time, but not a must-have.
📌 A handful of flaws that may impact overall enjoyment.
Competent but forgettable. There’s enjoyment to be had, but also frustration, missed potential, or uneven execution. The kind of experience you might enjoy if you’re already invested, but not something we’d recommend to everyone.
📌 Not bad, but not particularly good either.
📌 A mix of fun moments and frustrating ones.
📌 Might be worth checking out – but only at a discount.
An experience that fails to leave a strong impression. It’s functional but uninspired, the kind of thing you consume and immediately forget about. If you don’t have anything better to do, it’s fine. But if you do, spend your time elsewhere.
📌 Completely middle-of-the-road.
📌 Competent but lacking excitement or originality.
📌 Might appeal to die-hard fans, but not casual audiences.
A bad experience with flashes of potential that make its failure even more frustrating. Maybe the idea was great, but the execution is a mess. This is a waste of talent, time, and money.
📌 Some redeeming qualities, but not enough.
📌 Rushed, broken, or uninspired.
📌 Hard to recommend unless you’re really desperate.
A flawed, frustrating experience that completely fails in execution. Whether it’s a dull, repetitive story or cringe-inducing performances, this feels like a waste of time, money, and effort.
📌 Fails at delivering an enjoyable experience in almost every way.
📌 Some ideas might have worked with better execution, but they don’t.
📌 Not even fun in an ironic “so bad it’s good” way.
A spectacular failure that is actively frustrating. Whether it’s horrible design, cringeworthy dialogue, or sheer technical incompetence, this pushes you away at every turn. If you finish it, it won’t be for fun—just morbid curiosity.
📌 Poorly executed, confusing, or outright broken.
📌 Lacks any meaningful redeeming qualities.
📌 You’ll regret engaging with it—but you might laugh at how bad it is.
A complete failure. Broken, joyless, and unwatchable or unplayable, this should never have been released. Whether it’s game-breaking bugs, incoherent storytelling, or baffling choices, it fails on every level with nothing redeeming.
📌 Offers no entertainment, enjoyment, or technical competence.
📌 So flawed it feels unfinished—or should have stayed that way.
📌 Avoid at all costs—there’s nothing here worth salvaging.
Join our newsletter
© 2025 Merch Mates. All rights reserved.